The NewReview gave the album a 4.5 out of 5 and stated "The Trouble With Angels can best be described as a combination of the hammering juggernauts Short Bus and The Amalgamut wrapped in the catchiness of Title of Record. Some people say that it’s nearly impossible for a band to rewrite history after experiencing huge success and then fading. But with this album, Filter haven’t rewritten history; they have grabbed it by the neck and are choking the very life out of it."